Have a CD - Book or DVD you would
like reviewed on this site? Mail to:
The Serious Comedy Site
41 Deblois
St-Nicephore Qc J2A 2M6

Comedy Reviews - CD - Jamie Kilstein - Libel, Slander, & Sedition - Joe Schneider review

Amazon page

Stand-up Comedy CD
Stand Up Records 2011

Listening to Jamie Kilstein’s comedy CD Libel, Slander & Sedition, is like listening to Jonah Hill’s character from Superbad; he’s filled with pent-up rage, he thinks what he’s saying somehow matters, and while he can be amusing for a bit, after listening to him for a few sentences, you’re hoping Seth Rogen and Bill Hader come in to take over the scene.  Their voices are even eerily similar.  

Kilstein’s style for most of his album is to talk as fast as possible so that anybody listening can only assume that what he’s saying is funny because they can’t tell that his act is mostly just amateur-night material.  Much like many young comedians today, Kilstein clearly idolized David Cross and his sarcastic but incredibly sharp veracity.  However, Kilstein just can’t back it up like Cross can.  He rants like a 19-year old who just took his first college philosophy or history class, and has had his eyes opened to the world.  Essentially, picture a hippie living today, give him cocaine, and you’d probably end up with this album.  

One of the worst parts about his anger and angst is that he’s trying to be an elitist, holier-than-thou kind of guy, then goes on to admit how much of an idiotic screw-up he was/is, and he loses ALL credibility in what he’s saying (also similar to a hippie if you just keep listening).

Stand Up! Records CD Page

And whenever Kilstein decides to slow things down, because he’s either out of breath or running out of material, he always likes to throw in some f-bombs and other shock value words to seduce the audience into laughing while he makes his transition or catches his breath (note, these are not the only times Kilstein resorts to simple shock humor).  

Oh, he also enjoys going on rants in the middle of his rants.  These are surprisingly generally funny.  They have no substance to them, which seems to go against what he’s trying to do, but they are usually funny.  

All I can really say is that this is a forgettable album that you don’t need to listen to, much less buy.

Joe Schneider

Other Jamie Kilstein Reviews

Please Buy My Jokes: First comedy CD introduces a very promising, deceptively smart comic.

Zombie Jesus: Excellent CD for those who like edgy comedy.

Libel, Slander, & Sedition: Yelling does not rant comedy make.

Libel, Slander, & Sedition - Brett Watson review: Skip this.

Kindle DX, Free 3G, 3G Works Globally, Graphite, 9.7" Display with New E Ink Pearl Technology